Better quality in depressionera new england, a miserly businessman named benedict slade receives a longoverdue attitude adjustment one christmas eve when he is visited by three ghostly figures. The many adaptations of charles dickens a christmas carol ranked from worst to best, from a 1901 silent film to the 2009 computergenerated feature. My favorite christmas story is a christmas carol by charles dickens and i enjoy as many versions as possible every year. Whichever is your personal favorite, be sure to watch it during this holiday. A christmas carol 1994, ebenezer, a christmas carol 1910, and a christmas carol 1938 are just ok. One of the earliest cinematic adaptations of charles dickens immortal classic, mgms 1938 a christmas carol has all the magic of the season. A new christmas carol explores the roots of scrooges. Ebenezer scrooge is given a chance to reform and save his soul. Ranking the best and worst versions of a christmas carol. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol every year, around early december, i prepare myself for. When it comes to the holiday season, you cant turn on your tv without finding some adaptation of a christmas carol somewhere. But like any cultural touchstone, a christmas carol adaptations range from the delightful to the derivative. In the 2009 disneys a christmas carol, gary oldman was the voice for tiny tim. In an american town, an old bitter miser is given a ghostly chance at redemption on christmas eve.
Theatrical release edit originally intended as a 1939 release, a christmas carol was rushed into production in october 1938 and was finished in a matter of weeks. I have, you see, been watching the many film versions there have been of the charles dickens classic in an endeavour to find the best movie adaptation of a christmas carol. After the british misfire of three years earlier, the yanks gave it their first try with this outing, and its not much better. However, this christmas eve he will be visited by three spirits who will show him the errors of his ways. To celebrate the holidays, were looking at the five best film versions of a christmas carol. A christmas carol 1938 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. This 1984 madefortelevision version stars george c. I agree that versions of a christmas carol are a dime a dozen, but this one is the most beautiful to look at. With alastair sim, jack warner, kathleen harrison, mervyn johns.
Top 10 greatest a christmas carol adaptations youtube. Originally intended as a 1939 release, a christmas carol was rushed into production in october 1938 and was finished in. This is a musical version of charles dickens a christmas carol. A christmas carol is no exception and maybe that is why i enjoy so many of the movie versions, they all bring a similar story to the screen, for about 9095% of the time but there is those small differences, scenes added, scenes neglected, names given, situations expanded upon, all making for a fine story no matter which version one is viewing. With the holiday season around the corner, i thought it would be a fun time to take a look at two filmed versions of a christmas carol, and see how they stack up and compare to one another. Though many beloved christmas movies, and even some adaptations of a christmas carol itself, contain memorable musical moments, theres nothing inherent to the story of a christmas carol that lends itself to the genre of the musical. As he prepares for an overthetop live production of a christmas carol on christmas eve, frank is visited by a former. Its been adapted so many times, that most people would be hardpressed to say theyre not familiar with the story. Movie versions a christmas carol 1938 starring reginald owen, gene lockhart, kathleen lockhart, june lockhart, leo g. This change was also used in other versions such as scrooge 1970, mickeys christmas carol 1983, and a christmas carol 1984. A christmas carol coreen catenburg on august 5, 2019 at 11. He is visited by three ghosts and is given one last chance to change his. Yes, some are the sort of story you gather with family to enjoy every year, but some are.
This version of a christmas carol is quite simply the best. The 1951 adaptation of charles dickens timeless classic is perhaps the most faithful film version and alastair sims performance as scrooge is not to be. A christmas carol is as much a part of the christmas tradition as santa claus and mistletoe, so its no surprise that this year theres yet another film version of the classic story. Christmas carol movies, tv shows hollywood reporter. A christmas carol the most frightening and memorable appearances of jacob marley. Alistair sim is as marvelously miserly as he is merrily magnanimous.
On christmas eve, scrooge has a haunting nightmare from being visited by the ghost of his business partner, jacob marley. The movie 2001, an animated version produced by illuminated films christmas carol, ltdthe film consortiummbp. From the 1901 silent film called scrooge, or, marleys ghost to the 2009 full cgi 3d jim carrey version, a christmas carol is adapted for film, television, and stage perennially. The five best film adaptations of a christmas carol. A christmas carol the most frightening and memorable. A christmas carol comparing and contrasting the 1951 and.
He is visited by 4 ghosts and is shown visions of his past life and the consequences of his life on others. A christmas carol movie tv listings and schedule tv guide. Being a history of a christmas carol on film by richard jones. The four lads, johnny desmond, basil rathbone, robert weede.
Charles dickens timeless tale a christmas carol isnt. There have been many versions of christmas carol, films and plays. So on christmas eve, as you settle down to see whether youll be visited by three spirits, lets take a look at the best and worst christmas carols. A christmas carol 1951 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. In addition to the countless theater productions, screen adaptations of a christmas carol have appeared almost as regularly as christmas itself, starting with the 1901 british silent movie. And yet thats exactly what the 1970 film scrooge produced.
You really get the feel of victorian england in dickens time. For the purposes of this article, we will be looking at the 1951 live action version of the story starring alastair sim as scrooge, and the 2009 cgimotion capture version from director robert. My favorite versions of a christmas carol movie mom. For this list, were looking at the best tv and movies based on the famous 1843 novel by charles dickens. The 10 best adaptations of a christmas carol consequence. I love it in just about any of its movie incarnations. A viewers guide to various versions of a christmas carol. Best movie version of charles dickens a christmas carol. I supposed its possible for a person to be unfamiliar with charles dickens classic tale, despite the existence of tens of films and tv movie versions of a.
Here are the top 10 best adaptations of a christmas carol. Another short film version, and while this richard williams and chuck. Of course, there are many more versions of a christmas caroltoo many to list here. There have been 20 different films based on charles dickenss a christmas carol, if you consider the recent 3d version, disneys a christmas carol, starring jim carrey. We delve back into more than a century of a christmas carol movies to find the best and worst adaptations of dickens festive tale. Movie and tagged a christmas carol, book versus movie, christmas, ghost story, holiday, jim carrey, reason for the season by katharine l bookmark the permalink. Dickens timeless tinseled classic a christmas carol, in prose, being a ghost story of christmas has been told and retold manyfold over its release in the mid19th century. Reginald owen plays scrooge, and by plays, i mean he stands with his legs apart and bends over a bit. A christmas carol film adaptations best and worst movie. A christmas carol 2006, a computer animated adaptation featuring anthropomorphic animals in the lead. They really went out of their way to make it as lovely as possible. This is a ranking of all the various films, shorts, and episodes of the different versions of a christmas carol, my favorite christmas story.
Critically acclaimed and nominated for many awards, the albert finneyled film is one of the most. Alastair sim, michael hordern, diana quick director. In recent weeks ghosts, dozens maybe even thousands of them, have been appearing in my front room. Scrooge 1970 starring albert finney, sir alec guinness, edith evans and kenneth more.
Here is a list of all our christmas carol and scrooge movies. The ghost of christmas past shows his descent from a shunned, lonely boy, blamed by his father for the death of his mother to the moneyobsessed man who puts profit above humanity. My ranking of a christmas carol films and shows imdb. Scott and was directed by clive donner, who also edited a 1951 film version of the story titled scrooge. How many movie versions of a christmas carol have been. This time, he soars alongside the ghost of christmas past to revisit the very best adaptations of a christmas carol. Just how many versions of a christmas carol are there. Theres no comfort and joy in fxs excruciating christmas. Funny, heartfelt, goofy like you read about, and just all around muppet perfection, this version uses the story itself as the narrative as its being told by dickens gonzo. Fred, because his birth cost the life of his beloved sister. A christmas carol adaptations ranked from worst to best. A christmas carol got the treatment in 1977, and the result is a shadowy, atmospheric version with little in the way of set or special effects, allowing the excellent cast including michael hordem as scrooge to shine. A christmas carol 1951 starring alastair sim, meryvn johns, michael hordern and glyn dearman 86 min. The muppet christmas carol 1992 sadly, post jim henson, this fourth in the original run of the muppet movies is nonetheless a truly amazing adaptation of the dickens tale.
1173 1250 585 1073 853 103 195 436 345 864 1108 550 897 91 1422 1499 1337 1571 1596 1558 608 1118 137 1318 1393 341 976 693 567 176 1346 261 154 586 825